A well-chosen, well-managed vacation rental in Playa del Carmen or Tulum can earn a solid return. An average one often doesn't. The gap between the two is location, the building and management, and I see both sides every day as a property manager.
What the market data says (2026)
Independent trackers count about 10,900 active short-term rentals in Playa del Carmen and 8,400 in Tulum. Their average nightly rate is around US$140–150, with occupancy that looks low on paper, roughly 25% to 35% in Playa and 17% to 28% in Tulum (source: BNB Calc, 12 months to Sept. 2026).
Don't let those percentages scare you. They average in thousands of listings that are blocked by owners, badly priced or barely managed. A rental's performance depends on its location, its view and amenities, the number of bedrooms, the quality of the furnishing and photos and above all on its management. The better located and the better managed, the more profitable it is. As a property manager, that is exactly my job.
Playa del Carmen vs Tulum
| Playa del Carmen | Tulum | |
|---|---|---|
| Supply trend | Slightly down (-4% YoY) | Up (+4% YoY), many new projects |
| Demand | Year-round: tourists, digital nomads, long stays | Strongly seasonal, more event-driven |
| Strength | Walkability, beach, deepest resale market | Brand, design, higher rates in peak season |
| Watch out for | Noise near 5th Avenue and clubs | Oversupply in some zones, distance to the beach |
Seasonality
Revenue peaks in December and January, stays strong through Easter and is lowest in September and October (hurricane season). Plan your cash flow on a full year, not on a January screenshot.
A real example: a sea-view condo I manage
A one-bedroom apartment with a separate bedroom and a balcony, one block from the sea in downtown Playa del Carmen, in a building with pools, a gym and a rooftop with spectacular sea views. Real Airbnb results, 2023–2025:
| 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Occupancy | 59% | 59% | 66% |
| Nights booked | 218 | 212 | 241 |
| Gross earnings | US$19,248 | US$20,013 | US$22,692 |
| Net after Airbnb fees and taxes withheld | US$16,108 | US$16,836 | US$19,088 |
- Twice the market average occupancy (66% vs about 25–35% for Playa del Carmen).
- Revenue up 18% in two years thanks to pricing, reviews and longer stays (6.9 nights on average in 2025).
- High season almost full: 80% to 97% occupancy from January to March.
That is the difference professional management makes: dynamic pricing, fast replies, spotless cleaning and five-star reviews.
Airbnb bookings only; HOA, utilities and management fees not deducted. Every property is different: location, view, amenities and size change the results.
Taxes and rules
- Short-term rental income is taxed in Mexico: VAT (IVA) and income tax (ISR). Airbnb withholds part of it automatically and a local accountant files the rest.
- Quintana Roo requires registration of vacation rentals and collection of the state lodging tax.
- Check the building's rules: some condos forbid stays under 30 days.
How to pick a property that rents
- 1Walk to the beach or 5th Avenue in Playa; in Tulum, choose established zones like Aldea Zama or La Veleta over remote jungle lots.
- 2Rooftop pool, gym, good Wi-Fi and a desk: digital nomads pay for them.
- 31 and 2 bedrooms rent most often; lock-off units give two rentals in one. 3 and 4 bedrooms are scarce, so they rent very well too, especially to families and groups.
- 4Buy below market: pre-sale or an assignment gives you a margin from day one. Read my guide on pre-sale vs resale.
Let me run the numbers on your property
I'm a realtor and a property manager, so I know what units actually earn, not just what brochures promise. Send me a property, or your budget, and I'll prepare a realistic income projection.
Market figures: BNB Calc, Oct. 2026; the example uses real Airbnb results from a condo I manage (2023–2025). Results vary by property and management. Not financial advice.



